Sheppard, White, Kachergus, & DeMaggio, P.A. Attorneys & Counselors At Law
Call us anytime.
During office hours, call 904-356-9661
After office hours, call 904-727-7191

Regular office hours are 7:30 a.m. to 6:30 p.m.

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies the Types of "Replica" Antique Firearms That Felons May Possess

Last week, the Florida Supreme Court issued an opinion clarifying the types of firearms convicted felons may possess. Section 790.23 of the Florida Statutes prohibits convicted felons from possessing firearms. However, the law also exempts any firearm manufactured before 1918, or replicas of pre-1918 firearms. Weeks v. State involved a case against a convicted felon who hunted with a .50 caliber muzzle-loaded rifle. Weeks' rifle largely copied a pre-1918 firearm, but used a modern scope. 

The gun in question was a gift from Weeks' wife. She testified that she had researched the issue and determined that Weeks could use it without breaking the law. Weeks' father, a retired law enforcement firearm instructor, also determined that Weeks could legally use the rifle. However, when Weeks took the rifle hunting with him, a Florida Fish and Wildlife officer arrested him.

The First District Court of Appeal found that the felon-in possession statute violated the constitution. It held that the definition of "replica" was unconstitutionally vague. In other words, it found that punishing Defendants for breaking the law was unfair, since the statute failed give a clear definition of "replica".

Justice Pariente, writing on behalf of the Court, found the statute was not unconstitutionally vague. However, she still held the rifle was a replica antique. She found that the key to understanding the statute was a parenthetical list in the statute's definition of antique firearm. The definition reads: "any firearm manufactured in or before 1918 (including any matchlock, flintlock, percussion cap, or similar early type of ignition system)". Taking into account this list, the Court held that the defining feature of a replica firearm was its ignition system. Since the Defendant's rifle used a percussion cap, the Court found it was a replica, notwithstanding the modern scope.

While Justice Pariente's interpretation won the day, the Justices disagreed as to exactly how courts should construe the statute. Justice Canady came to the same conclusion, but argued that the firearm was a replica antique because "accessories" like scopes are not a part of the firearm. Justice Lewis came to a different conclusion, finding that the Black's Law definition of a "replica" required the copy to be a "reasonably exact duplicate." Therefore, according to Lewis, attaching a modern scope created a large enough difference to disqualify the firearm from the statutory exemption.

The Supreme Court's decision last-week gives convicted felons some much-needed guidance as to what types of firearms they may possess. One aspect in the case that was never in dispute was that the firearm was far too cumbersome to be of any danger. The trial judge quipped "[Weeks] would be in a world of hurt if a bear was charging after him." Given that the rifle generated three conflicting, well-reasoned legal opinions, one has to wonder why the State decided to prosecute Weeks. The evidence showed that he posed no threat to anyone and was merely trying to follow a very confusing law.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
email us for a response
  1. Best Lawyers Best Law Firms US News 2020 Martindale Hubbell AV Preeminent Peer Rated for highest level of Provisional Excellence 2020 Sheppard Best Lawyers Badge Employment 2019 Sheppard Best Lawyers Badge General Practice 2019 Best Lawyers Best Law Firms US News 2018 Best Lawyers|Lawyer Of The Year WM. J. Sheppard|Criminal Defense: White-Collor|Jacksonville Florida|2018
  2. Best Lawyers Best Law Firms US News 2017 Best Lawyers|Best Law Firms US News|Criminal Defense: White-Collor|Tier 1|Jacksonville|2017 Martindale-Hubbell Client Champion Silver / 2017 Best Lawyers Best Law Firms US News 2016 Martindale Hubbell AV Preeminent peer rated for high professional achievement 2020 William J.Sheppard Best Lawyers Lawyer of the year 2014
  3. American College of Trial Lawyers The Florida Bar Board Certified Best Lawyers Linking Lawyers And Clients Worldwide AV Martindale Hubbell Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability Super Lawyers

Sheppard, White, Kachergus, & DeMaggio, P.A. Attorneys & Counselors at Law.
215 N. Washington Street
Jacksonville, FL 32202

Phone: 904-727-7191
Phone: 904-356-9661
Fax: 904-356-9667
Map & Directions

Regular office hours are 7:30 a.m. to 6:30 p.m.

Back to top